Students at Baldwin Middle School have a variety of opportunities to engage in athletic and fitness activities. Beginning in seventh grade, students become eligible to join athletic extracurricular teams, competing against other middle schools in Nassau County.
| Sport | Coach |
|---|---|
| Baseball | Doug Rogers |
| Basketball - Boys | Rich Garguilo |
| Basketball - Girls | Nadia Elcock & Leroy Brown |
| Cheer | Francine Krieger |
| Field Hockey | Alexandra Gallo & Matt Boniberger |
| Football | Thomas Durnin & Rich Garguilo |
| Lacrosse - Boys | Sean Starke |
| Lacrosse - Girls | Taylah Hudson |
| Soccer - Boys | Chris Doherty |
| Soccer - Girls | Aisling Geraghty |
| Softball | TBA |
| Tennis - Girls | AnneMarie Pagano |
| Track and Field - Boys | Mike Robinson |
| Track and Field - Girls | Jordan Brown |
| Volleyball | Tom Llewellyn |
| Wrestling | TBD |